)

24. March 2023
Steak from a Petri dish? The future of in-vitro meat
Our blog series focuses on the future of food – and when it comes to meat consumption, there’s one topic we simply cannot overlook: in-vitro meat. It’s certainly a much-discussed subject, but can it do more than just divide opinion? This article explores where the potential lies and what limitations this production method (still) entails. Will we soon stop eating conventional meat altogether and instead be supplied with an alternative from laboratories? Or will lab-grown meat remain a culinary curiosity?
)
What does ‘in vitro meat’ mean?
The term In vitro comes from Latin and means in a glass. In-vitro research therefore does not take place within a living organism, but in a controlled environment. Specifically, this usually involves a test tube or a Petri dish in a laboratory. In the case of in vitro meat, the terms ‘lab-grown meat’, ‘cultured meat’ or ‘clean meat’ are also commonly used. The process involves extracting muscle stem cells from a living animal – for example, a cow. For the animal, this process is roughly comparable to having blood taken. These extracted stem cells are then cultivated with the addition of a nutrient solution. The result: real meat.
What are the benefits of in vitro meat?
It is not without reason that lab-grown meat has been a hot topic for more than a decade. Only recently, the Office for Technology Assessment at the German Bundestag recognised the great potential of cell-cultured meat – so the question of why is an obvious one.
Ethics & Climate
In terms of animal welfare, lab-grown meat offers clear advantages. Ideally, no animal needs to be slaughtered for this purpose. People who do not eat meat because of their love for animals might find it easier to accept these cell cultures and consume the resulting products. If more meat were produced as an in vitro product, the enormous livestock population would likely gradually decline. This, in turn, could have a positive impact on the climate: both the direct CO₂ impact of livestock – for example, through the emission of methane – and the associated journeys to abattoirs, etc., would be reduced.
Place
Another point is the issue of space: around 99 per cent less agricultural land is required. It is obvious that lab-grown meat requires less physical space than large livestock sheds and pastures, including slaughterhouses. Added to this is the land previously used to grow animal feed. With fewer animals, some of this land could be used to grow food for human consumption, such as cereals – a significant factor in the global fight against hunger.
Health
Whether, and to what extent, in vitro meat is healthier than that produced using conventional methods can only be definitively determined once it has been consumed on a representative scale. However, it stands to reason that cell cultures are less harmful to health than the conventional method. After all, this method of production is highly unlikely to require antibiotics, and the risk of zoonotic diseases is also reduced. In particular, if plant-based alternatives are used as a nutrient source instead of so-called foetal calf serum, the likelihood of the product being free from pathogens is high.
What are the drawbacks of this manufacturing method?
Where there is light, there is also shadow – that’s how it is with almost everything in life. The same applies to in-vitro meat. After all, there are reasons why we have not yet fully switched to this method of meat production. “There are still many unanswered questions regarding sustainability, regional production and the role of agriculture in the future,” Food trend researcher Hanni Rützler is also certain that.
Current state of research
Since 2013, when the first lab-grown burger – costing the equivalent of around 250,000 euros – was produced, there has been little significant progress. Whilst in-vitro meat is available in some restaurants in Israel and Singapore, at prices of around 15 euros, but these remain the exception. Despite various start-ups and research projects, the widespread market launch of lab-grown meat is apparently still a long way off. And the steak referred to in the title of this blog post, in particular, seems to be causing difficulties. Like a fillet, it has a texture that is not as easy to reproduce as that of minced meat. Even though prices have already fallen significantly, there is still a long way to go before they reach the level of conventionally produced meat.
Resource consumption
For the harvested cells to grow, they need to be kept at the same temperature they would have been at whilst still in the animal. Consequently, if in-vitro meat is to be produced on a large scale, huge bioreactors will be required for the stem cells – along with corresponding amounts of energy. Furthermore, the meat can only be produced without the death of animals if the foetal calf serum mentioned above is replaced by algae or other plant-based or genetically modified alternatives. Otherwise, one bovine foetus and its mother die for every half a litre produced. In that case, it can hardly be described as ‘free from animal suffering’.
Rejection
Finally, the question remains as to when lengthy approval processes and patent-related issues will be resolved. And whether Western culture is open to such an ‘artificial’ product. Individual surveys and public opinion indicate that there is a certain underlying scepticism. Rejection can take many forms, ranging from fear to revulsion – and the associated prejudices must first be overcome.
Is lab-grown meat vegan?
No. As it is real meat derived from an animal, in-vitro meat is not animal-free and is therefore not vegan. However, under the specified conditions, it can be produced largely without causing animal suffering. People who sometimes find it difficult to stick to their chosen vegetarian or vegan lifestyle might find this a viable compromise.
Outlook: What does the future hold for lab-grown meat?
As hardly any company is willing to reveal its hand regarding the current state of development, it is difficult to make predictions about market entry. The fact remains, however, that in-vitro meat produced from stem cells could represent an opportunity for the meat of the future – ideally using a plant-based culture medium. And Germany should invest in relevant research – if only to avoid falling behind other countries. It is equally clear, however, that reducing meat consumption is definitely advisable, regardless of where the meat comes from.
How Ehlert can enhance any type of meat
As a specialist supplier to the food industry, Gustav Ehlert GmbH offers an extensive range of products. We have the products that help ensure your food is of the highest quality. This ranges from disposable gloves, which maintain the necessary hygiene standards, through to spice blends that enhance the flavour of in vitro meat, and includes a variety of machines.
Ready for the future – with modern technology and high-quality products. We’d be delighted to support you every step of the way!
Your contact person
)
More articles

)
)


